Top 5 Best Organic Eye Primers

Published Categorized as Makeup Tips

The beauty world is a limitless place for products of all types, brands, colors, prices – you name it!

Hi beautiful! Just to let you know, we earn a modest commission off of purchases made through Amazon affiliate links on this page. Don't worry, it's of no extra cost to you. We love the products we recommend in this post, and we hope you do, too!

Knowing how to find an item of makeup that is not only suitable for you and your skin tones and eye color, but is also organic and cruelty free can be pretty tricky to do. This gets even more difficult depending on the type of makeup product you are in search for.

Looking for the best eye primer that works with your coloring and makeup style can be a tricky task in itself, but ensuring that you find the best organic eye primer can be even more difficult.

Well try not to worry, we’re here to make your life easier. Today let’s introduce you to the 5 best eye primers that are accessible and affordable, so by the end of this article you will have a new product that makes your eyes pop!

Table of Contents

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Ultimate Shadow & Liner Primer, Eyeshadow & Eyeliner Primer - Light

Best Organic Eye Primers

Many eye primers are full of chemicals, so today  we are specifically going to look at not only natural eye primer, the best non toxic eyeshadow primer as well, to help you protect your skin and your eyes as much as possible.

Here are our favorite best organic eye primers to help you achieve that perfect eye look:

Prices pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:

Elizabeth Mott Thank Me Later Eye Primer

Cruelty-Free and Paraben-Free Eye Primer Makeup Eyeshadow Base: Elizabeth Mott Thank Me Later Eye Shadow Base to Prevent Oily Lids and Creasing - Clear Waterproof Eyeshadow Primer for All Shadows (10g)
Buy on Amazon

First up we have the Elizabeth Mott Thank Me Later Eye Primer. This is cruelty-free, affordable eye primer has Leaping Bunny approval for its choice in ingredients and the testing that it undergoes causes no harm in the process.

This eye primer not only creates a smooth and even base for you to apply your eyeshadow, but it also helps to balance out skin tone and conceals discoloration and complexion. It works with particularly oily lids so that nobody has to worry about touch-ups or heaviness when wearing their makeup.

NYX Professional Makeup Ultimate Primer

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Ultimate Shadow & Liner Primer, Eyeshadow & Eyeliner Primer - Light
Buy on Amazon

Next up we have the NYX Ultimate Primer. This primer for the eyes is promoted as vegan and is PETA approved, meaning its ingredients are not tested on animals.

This comes in cream form and is available in multiple colors so that you can get the best one, closest to your skin tone, which helps to provide a more natural and even base.

As it is a cream, it is important to let it set before applying further makeup on top. Once dried, it provides a soft and even base for the rest of your application.

This primer is infused with vitamin E, helping to not only extend the makeup wear, but creates a more vibrant base, giving you a much more saturated final look. The cream sets and provides a no-smudge, no-crease, and long-lasting look for you to work with.

PURE AloeCare Organic Makeup Primer Cream

PURE AloeCare Organic Aloe Vera Vitality Hydrating Makeup Primer Cream, Offers Deep Hydration and Skin Loving Botanical Nutrients, Creates an All Day Barrier to Lock in Moisture 1.7 oz (50g)
Buy on Amazon

Number three in the running is the natural, organic, makeup primer from PURE AloeCare. Whilst this is a primer available to use on the face, it is also promoted as being perfect for the eyes. That means that this primer is a 2 in 1 job, helping you to save money on your beauty products!

Again, this is a cream, but comes in a more moisturizing texture. Whilst it takes slightly longer to set and dry, the moisturizing agents help to keep your skin smooth and hydrated which is important if you are often applying and removing makeup.

This primer helps create a protective barrier that keeps your skin fresh but allows your eyeshadow to be perfectly applied. It is enriched with natural shea butter, aloe vera, hyaluronic acid which helps to hydrate without any oil, and finally it has botanical nutrients to help keep your skin nourished and soft.

Lavera Eyeshadow Base

Lavera Lavera eye shadow base, 0.3oz, 0.3 Ounce
Buy on Amazon

This Lavera eyeshadow primer is a natural, vegan, and organic eyeshadow base that helps your makeup stay on for hours.

It is extremely affordable and the reviews are through the roof! Not only does it help your eyeshadow application go smoothly, but many users also apply it to their lashes first which helps your mascara to stay on for longer.

The smooth texture of this primer helps your eyeshadow sit evenly whilst sticking, meaning the eyeshadow does not fall under your eye and risks creating that dark shadow that can often happen during makeup application.

The primer works perfectly with mineral-based eyeshadow. Whilst you ma often find yourself having to top up mineral-based eyeshadow, you no longer will have to with just a little drop of this beforehand!

Gabriel Cosmetics Eyeshadow Primer

Gabriel Cosmetics Eyeshadow Primer, 0.07 oz.
Buy on Amazon

Finally, we have the Gabriel Cosmetics eye primer. This is potentially the best clean eye primer. It is made up of natural ingredients and is 100% vegan and cruelty free.

It provides a matte finish which means that your eyeshadow application will be smooth and flawless. Their mineral-based ingredients help to keep the skin nourished and soft, meaning no harsh chemicals can damage the skin and potentially ruin the makeup application.

It also comes in many other tones which can help create a different base depending on the eyeshadow look you are going for. Whilst most primers aim to match your skin tone, you can create a lighter or darker base if necessary, depending on what you are applying on top.

Many users who often suffer from sensitive skin have said that this eye primer causes no irritation and provides a fresh and light feel when worn, helping to keep you looking alive and vibrant all night long without that heavy eye feel that many makeup products bring.

What Is Eye Primer?

Similar to a primer that you would use for your face, eye primer is used to improve your eye’s skin texture. It helps your eyeshadow be applied better. Also, it helps have a smoother, more even finish that will last a much longer time.

Eye primer works as a base coat to help bond the eyeshadow to your eye without your natural skin and oils causing clumps or uneven application. The creases in your eyes, much like the rest of your face, can cause makeup to bunch up and congeal together if worn for a long time. Primer is perfect for preventing this from happening.

Prices pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:

Best Organic Eye Primers: Final Thoughts

Whatever makeup you decide to use, it is important to not only check the ingredients, but make sure you are applying it properly.

Primer has to be set in order to create that flawless base. So having patience and applying the right amount can really be the make or break to your look.

All of these recommendations we gave for best organic eye primers are readily available on Amazon. But some are also available in most drugstores, making them super easy to access! They’re affordable, too!

Whichever you decide to go for, follow our tips. Pick the right tone, have the right application, and your eyeshadow will be more flawless than you have ever seen. Get ready to make your eyes pop all night long!

More primer posts on the blog:

By Ellis James

We design luxuriously glamorous bags, organizers and life essentials for you. At Ellis James Designs, it’s all about YOU. Your bag, Your way. Our exclusive designs are timeless, indulgent and most importantly inspired by you. What will be your first Ellis James Design?

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *