The Best Eye Primer for Mature Skin – Long Lasting Eyeshadow Performance

Published Categorized as Makeup Tips

Choosing makeup once your skin has begun to mature can be a lot trickier than it may seem. Products that you once swore by and wore religiously may not longer take the same shape and effect on your face.

Table of Contents

Best Eye Primer For Mature Skin

It is important as you grow to adapt your makeup and skin routine to what is happening with your face as well.

Hi beautiful! Just to let you know, we earn a modest commission off of purchases made through Amazon affiliate links on this page. Don't worry, it's of no extra cost to you. We love the products we recommend in this post, and we hope you do, too!

As skin matures, fine lines and wrinkles begin to develop. Often people find they have darker areas and circles around their eyes, and can even get some redness and blemishing.

Skin that was once dry may become naturally oily, and skin that was once oily may begin to dry out. There really is no way of knowing what is going to happen to your skin. But remaining in touch with it and experimenting with different products as you grow is key to looking and feeling as young as possible.

The eyes tell a lot about somebody, and with frown lines and laughter lines, even with bags from tiredness, the eyes are one area of the face that we may see the most changes happening.

As the skin around your eyes matures, applying makeup becomes a lot harder. With creases and lines and discoloration that wasn’t always there, the best thing you can do before makeup application is use a primer.

Now, finding the right primer is a whole other question in itself. So I have decided to make the job a lot easier for you. I have narrowed down some of the best eye primers for mature skin based on various categories and skin types making your life a lot easier!

All you need to do now is give this a read, find the product for you, and have brighter eyes forever!

Prices pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:

Best Eye Primer for Mature Skin – Revlon Colorstay 24 Hour Eye Primer

Eyeshadow Primer by Revlon, ColorStay 24 Hour Eye Primer, Longwearing & Non-Drying Formula Infused wiith Shea Butter, 100 Universal, 0.33 Oz
Buy on Amazon

Coming in as the overall best eye primer for mature skin we have the Revlon Colorstay primer. This is an extremely affordable, easy to use primer that can be bought online but also in most drugstores.

It is in a gel formula and works with all skin tones. The Colorstay technology allows for all day, vibrant wear and lasts for 24 hours!

The gel creates a smooth base, perfect for those with fine lines and wrinkles, and using a shea butter care complex it hydrates and revitalizes the skin around the eyes.

It is a non-drying, but also non-greasy product, making it ideal for anyone who may suffer from dryness, but also great for those with oil skin who do not need extra grease during makeup application.

Using a tapered brush can be an excellent way for getting into those hard to reach areas when applying your primer. It will create a more even and balanced look around the eye.

It is a fantastic product which works for so many different skin types out there, making it the number one best eye primer for mature skin!

Eyeshadow Eye Primer

With primers, they have many different jobs and roles. Typically, most people look for a primer that helps keep their eyeshadow on.

Those with mature skin also need this. However many people with fine lines and wrinkles also look for under eye primer to help smooth the skin out below the eye.

I am going to categorize some of the best eye primers into eyeshadow primers and undereye primers to make it easier for you to find exactly what you want.

Best Eyeshadow Primer for Mature Skin

Too Faced Shadow Insurance Anti-Crease Eyeshadow Primer

Too Faced Shadow Insurance Anti-Crease Eyeshadow Primer 0.35 oz
Buy on Amazon

Too Faced takes the lead when it comes to the best eyelid primer for hooded eyes. If you find that your eyeshadow is often getting sticky in the creases of your eyes and developing lines as it gathers, you need a primer designed to stop this.

Those with more hooded eyelids can experience their eyeshadow beginning to gather within a couple of hours which can become really annoying. Using a primer designed to prevent creasing and grouping is a fantastic method for those with hooded eyelids to keep their makeup on for a lot longer.

Too Faced have introduced a primer designed specifically for this job. The primer has an extremely creamy texture which, whilst never feeling greasy, never feels sticky.

Despite not feeling sticky, it holds the eyeshadow in place for as long as you need it to! That’s why this primer is not only fantastic for all eye-types, but for those with mature skin and who’s eyelids may have started to hood over, this is the best eyeshadow primer for you!

ELF Shadow Primer

Eyelid Primer
Buy on Amazon

This ELF shadow primer comes in a sheer nude color and has very easy application. The wand and doe end means that you can reach into the smaller cracks and crevices around the eyes, allowing for a more even and balanced finish.

The formula is extremely smooth to the skin but also provides a flawless finish, meaning that those with mature skin are left with a much flatter canvas to apply their eyeshadow to.

Not only is it a fantastic product, but it comes in at one of the cheapest, and most easily accessible, ranking itself not as the best primer, but as the best drugstore eye primer for mature skin.

It is a strong contestant with its smooth base and long-lasting effects, however the only downfall is that it can be hard to blend. Whilst it helps the colors to stick, it can be difficult to blend colors on this primer and often any shadowing seems to fade away.

Smashbox Photo Finish Primer

Smashbox Photo Finish Foundation Primer for Women, Transparent, , 1 Fl Oz (Pack of 1)
Buy on Amazon

The Smashbox primer is one of the best primers out there for mature skin, particularly the best eye primer for oily, mature skin. It is easy and affordable, and the color with a matte finish means that it can be doubled up and used as a blemish or concealer stick as well!

Although it is fantastic for oiler eyelids because it is slightly drying, for those with mature and dry skin, this may dry your eye area out slightly.

For those with naturally oily skin, this primer is great for absorbing and evening out skin tone, even for those with wrinklier skin. However, for those who have slightly wrinklier, dry skin, this primer may enhance your wrinkles more with its drying effects and which is why it is so important to find a primer suitable to your skin type.

Typically this primer can last up to 12 hours, however when it comes to the best eye primer for mature skin, this does not take the lead for anyone who does not have typically oily skin.

Under Eye Primer

Whilst these products are often focussed on helping to soften eyelids in order to apply eyeshadow, mature skin can sometimes call out for help under the eye as well.

Finding a product that can help to smooth the skin under your eyes can really help to brighten up your face as a whole and make those with mature skin look a lot younger.

Best under eye primer for mature skin

Colorscience Total Eye 3-in-1 Renewal Therapy

Colorescience Total Eye 3-in-1 Renewal Therapy, 0.23 Fl Oz, Medium
Buy on Amazon

This beauty stick is not only a fantastic primer, but is amazing for fighting dark circles and under eye bags.

Whilst this product is on the more expensive end, the application only requires very little and so it goes a long way.

Colorscience Total Eye also includes a cooling agent which helps to reduce puffiness and redness around the eyes, leaving your eyes looking brighter and younger. Reducing redness and puffiness gives mature skin an overall younger look but also helps to smooth your eyes for any under eye makeup application following.

Moreover, this amazing product also contains SPF 35. This means that whilst it help you appear younger, it also helps you to protect your skin and keep it as wrinkle-free and young as possible, even when in the sun!

Finally, this is an approved product by ophthalmologists and is suitable for those who have sensitive skin, making it the best under eye primer for mature skin as it is accessible and suitable for those of all skin types.

ELF Hydrating Under Eye Primer

Pack of 2 e.l.f. Hydrating Under Eye Primer, Clear 81119
Buy on Amazon

If you already have a concealer and foundation that you are happy with, then ELF hydrating primer is one of the most amazing primers for helping them stick.

It works by smoothing out the creases under the eye, making application of concealer and foundation a lot smoother. This is perfect for those with mature skin as it creates an amazing base for further makeup application.

Not only does it smooth out the skin before makeup application, but it has a hydrating formula which helps with any dryness or sensitivity around the eyes and leaves you feeling refreshed and ready for the day.

This primer comes in a peach tone which is fantastic for color correction and evening out any dark circles that often form as skin matures.

Finally, it is certified by PETA and is completely vegan and cruelty-free, making it not only one of the best under eye primers for mature skin, but also possibly the best vegan under eye primer on the market.

Olay Regenerist Anti-Aging Wrinkle Revolution Complex Moisturizer Plus Primer

Wrinkle Cream by Olay Regenerist Anti-Aging Wrinkle Revolution Complex Moisturizer Plus Primer, 50 mL
Buy on Amazon

Finally, we have this beauty coming in as the best under eye primer for dry and mature skin. Not only does the Olay primer work as a fantastic primer, but its main focus is to moisturize the areas around the eye, meaning that those who suffer from typically dry and mature skin around the eyes can have a product that does just about everything they need!

It helps to hydrate and soften the skin around your eyes and uses a special formula containing bio-peptides and vitamin B3 complex, helping it revitalize and bring the skin around your eyes back to life!

It has a micro-filler technology which ensures it fills out and smooths the skin whilst remaining non-greasy and fresh-feeling to the skin.

It helps remove blemishes and wrinkles leaving you with the perfect surface to apply further makeup, but also works as a moisturizer, keeping the skin hydrated and you feeling awake and ready for the day ahead! What more could you want?

Prices pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:

Final Thoughts

Overall, there are many amazing eye primers out there that are specific to helping those with matured skin.

It really depends on your skin type, what you want to use it for, and where you want to use it.

For those with aged skin around the eyes, ensuring you keep the skin hydrated whilst also looking fuller is key to looking younger, but also creating a good base for makeup application.

Whilst certain primers are ideal for all areas of the eye, using one specific to eyelids or under eyes can be great if you are focussed more on eyeshadow application or if you care more about revitalizing the skin under your eyes.

Whatever it be, give the products on this list a go and let me know your thoughts!


Does Eye Primer help with wrinkles?

Eye primer helps to fill out finale lines and wrinkles, making application of makeup a lot easier and even but also helping to brighten your eyes. Some primers come with moisturizing and hydrating formulas which will help to smooth out wrinkles and prevent more wrinkles from forming.

How do you keep makeup from wrinkling under your eyes?

Using an under eye primer is the best way to stop makeup from wrinkling under the eyes. Creating a smooth base will allow the makeup to stick to the base and not be shifted by the naturally lines on your face.

By Ellis James

We design luxuriously glamorous bags, organizers and life essentials for you. At Ellis James Designs, it’s all about YOU. Your bag, Your way. Our exclusive designs are timeless, indulgent and most importantly inspired by you. What will be your first Ellis James Design?